Office of the Governor of Iowa
Gov. Terry E. Branstad
Iowa Department of Justice
Attorney General Tom Miller
For Immediate release -- Wednesday, November 27, 1996
- Contact Eric Woolson (515-281-3150) or Bob Brammer (515-281-6699)
Iowa Files Lawsuit Against Tobacco Companies
DES MOINES. The State of Iowa has filed a lawsuit seeking
to recover millions of dollars in restitution and damages from tobacco
companies and their research associations, Governor Terry Branstad and
Attorney General Tom Miller said today in a joint announcement at the State
Capitol in Des Moines.
In a suit filed by Miller, the State alleges that the
defendants violated Iowa's Consumer Fraud Act by "repeatedly and systematically
misleading the public" about the health dangers of smoking and failing
to disclose the addictive qualities of nicotine. The suit seeks restitution
and civil penalties on the consumer fraud count.
The suit also asks the court to order the defendants to
pay the State millions of dollars in restitution for costs the State paid
to provide health care and other services to citizens and employees as
a result of tobacco-related diseases, illnesses and injuries resulting
from "the defendants' wrongful conduct and unlawful activities. "
Branstad said he supports the lawsuit. "Approximately
one in five deaths -- more than 400,000 people each year -- are attributed
to smoking," he said. "for too long, taxpayers have footed the
bill for the immense strain that smoking has caused on our health care
system. With this suit, we are seeking justice."
About 5,000 Iowans died from smoking-related illnesses
last year. According to the suit, the State of Iowa spends millions of
dollars each year for health care, facilities and services for indigents
and other eligible residents and employees with tobacco-related diseases.
The suit seeks to recover those taxpayer costs, mostly paid by Medicaid.
"This is a law enforcement issue about the conduct
of the tobacco companies," Miller said. "It's similar to many
other consumer fraud lawsuits we have filed over the years. We allege that
the defendants engaged in deception, false promises, omissions, concealment
and unfair practices in their sale of tobacco products. "
The 100 page lawsuit painstakingly argues that the tobacco
defendants "have known for decades of the lethal dangers of smoking
their cigarettes, "from as early as the 1930s -- and that the basic
elements of the "industry strategy of deception are intact today."
Miller said, The suit is lengthy, but what we allege is
simple: Cigarette manufacturers have known for decades that nicotine is
addicting, and that their products cause cancer, other diseases, and death.
Yet they have made every effort to hide from the public their own research
that shows this, and to misrepresent the facts about smoking, health and
addiction. "
Branstad noted that the suit cites State Department of
Public Health estimates that almost one in four of Iowa's 725,000 children
under age 18 are expected to start smoking "Thirty thousand Iowa children
are already smoking, and more than a third of them are daily smokers who
illegally consume about three million packs of cigarettes per year, "
Branstad said. To be sure, tobacco's long-term health and economic damages
extend beyond current smokers."
The suit asks the court to curtail the promotion and sale
of tobacco products to minors in Iowa.
"The lawsuit is a huge undertaking Miller said. "We
have spent months assembling all the legal and financial resources and
preparing the suit, and the suit itself probably will take several years.
The tobacco defendants have a reputation for fighting these suits hard.
We are very grateful for the support of Gov. Branstad and others."
Miller said at least four Iowa health-related organizations
have stepped forward to contribute to the litigation expenses. Blue Cross
and Blue Shield of Iowa has pledged $50,000 a year for up to four years.
The Iowa Medical Society, Iowa Hospitals and Health Systems, and Iowa Health
Systems each have pledged $5,000 per year.
The State Executive Council also approved using outside
counsel set to work with Miller's Office on the case. Five law firms will
participate: Dickinson, Mackaman, Tyler & Hagen, P.C., Des Moines;
Ralph Walker Law Firm, P.C, Des Moines; Simmons, Perrine Albright &
Ellwood PLC, Cedar Rapids; Hawkins & Norris, Des Moines and Ness, Motley,
Loadholt, Richardson & Poole, Charleston, S.C . By using the law firms
who will also absorb up-front costs to fund the litigation the State will
avoid out-of-pocket costs.
Miller said taxpayer funds would not be needed for the
suit, and his office would not need to add additional staff, thanks to
the outside counsel and the generous financial contributions of the Iowa
health groups. If the State prevails, it would ask the court to require
the tobacco companies to pay for the cost of litigation, Miller said.
Miller and Branstad were surrounded at the State Capitol
announcement by members of the "Tobacco-Free Action Team" coalition,
or T-FACT made up of advocates from the American Cancer Society, American
Heart Association, American Lung Association, and others. Miller said he
planned to undertake other tobacco initiatives in legislation, enforcement,
and citizen education, especially efforts to deter Iowa youth from taking
up tobacco.
Branstad and Miller were scheduled to visit other cities
Wednesday to announce the lawsuit and speak to citizens about tobacco issues:
Davenport, Cedar Rapids, Mason City, Sioux City, and Council Bluffs.
The lawsuit was filed in Polk County District Court. The
lawsuit is in State court and is independent from suits filed previously
by attorneys general in other states.
Defendants named in the lawsuit are: R.J. Reynolds Tobacco
Company; RJR Nabisco, Inc.; The American Tobacco Company; American Brands,
Inc; Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corporation; B.A.T. Industries, PLC;
Batus Holdings, Sac.; British American Tobacco Company, Ltd.; British-American
(Holdings) Ltd.; Philip Morris, Incorporated (Philip Morris U.S.A.); Philip
Morris Companies, Ine.; Liggett & Myers, Inc.; Liggett Group, Inc.;
The Brooke Group, Limited; Lorillard Tobacco Company; Lorillard Incorporated;
Loews Corporation; United States Tobacco Company; UST, Inc.; The Council
for Tobacco Research; The Tobacco Institute, Inc.; and Hill & Knowlton,
Inc.
- 30 -